Home Unfiltered Articles Stats Glossary
Baseball       
Hockey Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here for forgotten password Click here to subscribe

2013 NHL Entry Draft - Top draft prospects list and analysis

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Buyers and Sellers (03/02)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Dropping The Puck (11/11)
Next Column >>
Dropping The Puck (03/10)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Howe and Why (03/03)

March 3, 2011
Dropping The Puck
Edmonton Reactions

by Kent Wilson

Printer-
friendly

This week in the puck drop we look at some Oiler fan reactions to the trade of Dustin Penner as well as the evolution of the modern enforcer and how the Leafs shots have broken down this year.

• Tyler Dellow looks at the Dustin Penner trade and shakes his head. He condemns both the Oilers management for their lack of vision and the hometown fans and media for continuously giving a pass to the club's ineptitude:

"Joseph de Maistre said that every country has the government it deserves. Edmonton, with the rink full every night to watch a terrible team and a media that exists to rationalize and justify the decisions of people like Lowe and Tambellini by way of terrible logic and faulty reasoning, has the hockey team that it deserves. It might get lucky and have a decent team in a few years time if a bunch of these young players turn out but that won't be the team that it deserves - it will be the team that the NHL's cartel policies gift them with. Don't get too used to it - they'll screw it up again. And Edmonton will deserve it."

• Over at Behind The Net, Gabriel Desjardins looks at the specialization of enforcers in What Does it Take to be a Goon? Desjardins shows that goons have steadily gotten bigger and heavier over the years, gradually changing from ill-tempered, average-sized skaters to lumbering pugilists. Ironically, this evolution of goons from simply the meanest guy on the team to a designated giant who can't actually play hockey at the NHL level is the reason enforcers are an anachronism in a capped NHL environment. Like a mutant variant in a species that no longer confers an adaptive advantage, the current version of the goon is vestigial and bound to be bred out of the game altogether eventually.

• Back to the Edmonton Oilers, Derek Zona of Copper and Blue looks back fondly on Dustin Penner's time with the team. Although frequently denounced as "unmotivated" and "having a poor work ethic", Penner was frequently one of the club's top three forwards during his tenure in Edmonton, despite playing on a lousy team and frequently against top six opposition.

Penner's contributions extended beyond production and underlying numbers, however, and Zona relates how he stood up for teammates and was a valued member of the community off the ice. He should be a good addition for the Kings going forward.

• Finally, Steve Burch of Pension Plan Puppets examines at the Leafs shot locations this season. He perused ESPN game-cast and collated the distance and location of each shot Toronto has managed thus far. According to Burch (and ESPN shot counters), the Leafs have averaged 8.69 "good" shots (from scoring locations) this season and 20.5 "bad" shots (per game). The club scored on 17.25% of good shots and just 5.04% on bad ones.

Follow the links for more details and discussion.

0 comments have been left for this article.

<< Previous Article
Premium Article Buyers and Sellers (03/02)
<< Previous Column
Premium Article Dropping The Puck (11/11)
Next Column >>
Dropping The Puck (03/10)
Next Article >>
Premium Article Howe and Why (03/03)

RECENTLY AT HOCKEY PROSPECTUS
NHL Playoffs, Stanley Cup Finals: Chicago Bl...
Top 100 Draft Prospects 2013: 91-100
Premium Article Conn Smythe Watch: Rask Leads Race
Top 100 Draft Prospects 2013: 81-90
Top 100 Draft Prospects 2013: 71-80

MORE FROM MARCH 3, 2011
Premium Article Howe and Why: Finding Hot Teams with PDO

MORE BY KENT WILSON
2011-03-18 - Dropping The Puck: Spectacularly Wrong Simul...
2011-03-17 - Premium Article Stats and Fury: Hope for the NHL's Worst Fiv...
2011-03-10 - Dropping The Puck: You Don't Need To Be a Ne...
2011-03-03 - Dropping The Puck: Edmonton Reactions
2011-02-23 - Premium Article Deadline Deals: Northwest Division
2011-02-07 - Stats and Fury: The Unlucky Ones
2011-01-11 - Premium Article Stats and Fury: Tug of War
More...

MORE DROPPING THE PUCK
2011-03-26 - Dropping The Puck: Possession
2011-03-18 - Dropping The Puck: Spectacularly Wrong Simul...
2011-03-10 - Dropping The Puck: You Don't Need To Be a Ne...
2011-03-03 - Dropping The Puck: Edmonton Reactions
2010-11-11 - Premium Article Dropping The Puck: Ovechkin and Stamkos in t...
2010-11-08 - Premium Article Dropping The Puck: Rise of the St. Louis Blu...
2010-11-03 - Dropping The Puck: Is Columbus Good?
More...